[ Handsome is boring because of how general it is, but fine, he'll work with it. ]

Mine? [ Seriously? He stretches his arms forward, even pulls a feet out of the water as he talks ] Perhaps this gorgeous face, a body of a young god, a pair of strong, gentle arms... [ At least his tone makes it clear that he's joking and not being serious. He's just going for that over-the-top boast, to show how varied answer Archer could give. But maybe he'll answer the question too. So he turns just a bit to have their gazes connect ]

But all that aside, I think the eyes are the best of my features.