Or maybe her fingers were so skinny that the ring just fell in?

[Just a random hypothesis from Sheryl, but it still doesn't make sense. She nods, carefully plucking the ring between two fingers and lifting it to her face. Such an expensive looking piece of jewelry with an intricate design... she just can't help but look on in awe.]

What you said makes more sense. Anyway, we found it! Let's give it to that girl right away.